1. Do you need support for Assetto Corsa Competizione? Please use the proper forum below and ALWAYS zip and attach the WHOLE "Logs" folder in your c:\users\*youruser*\AppData\Local\AC2\Saved. The "AppData" folder is hidden by default, check "Hidden items" in your Windows view properties.
    Dismiss Notice

Damage and Collisions

Discussion in 'ACC General Discussions' started by HemiR, Jul 17, 2018.

  1. HemiR

    HemiR Gamer

    Will we see proper visual damage in ACC , detaching parts and such. ?
    Please for the love of god make your collisions models represent the constraints of the visual car this time round..it is vital for online racing.

    Cheers
    Looking forward to it.
     
    Last edited: Jul 18, 2018

  2. Similar Threads
    Forum Title Date
    ACC Gameplay Shock induced damage Sep 20, 2018
    ACC Gameplay AI cars following slowly a damaged car, creating the train Sep 13, 2018
    ACC General Discussions Hardcore racing expirience(visual and mechanical damage) POLL Mar 9, 2018
    ACC General Discussions More abusive damage system (not visual) Mar 2, 2018
    ACC General Discussions Damage model?? Feb 22, 2018
    Chit Chat Room A damaged gearbox can be repaired during pit stop? Nov 26, 2017
    Chit Chat Room Is there a way to disable visual damage in replay? Nov 4, 2017
    Suggestions Rear wing vs Front wing damage Sep 24, 2017
    Console Lounge Gearbox damage on console Aug 23, 2017
    Physics Bugs & Issues AI escaping to pits does not fix damage Jul 23, 2017
    Troubleshooting - Workarounds Damaged AI cars did not retire May 27, 2017
    Suggestions Variable Damage % per driver - Server Side May 18, 2017
    Console Lounge Lotus 98T engine damage May 9, 2017
    Chit Chat Room Damage Indicator Folder Contents Mar 12, 2017
    Physics Bugs & Issues Alfa Romeo Giulietta QV - no gearbox damage Mar 3, 2017

  3. Typer

    Typer Simracer

    Sure, that would be cool and all, but “vital”? Really?
     
    After_Midnight and Serge M like this.
  4. Serge M

    Serge M Alien

    Yeah, I’m going to second the cool but certainly not vital thing. Shouldn’t be hitting people anyway :)
     
  5. Threads like this one just show how varied and numerous the things that need to be considered and then addressed actually are. That is something that I never really have thought about. A must have for some and added bonus for others I guess .
     
  6. HemiR

    HemiR Gamer

    Maybe not vital for every person. certainly not the casual gamer . But for league racers who can run so close together, we felt it was and is..
    I should mention I posted screens shots in the AC forum regarding the Collisions models and how far out they are compared to the visual model , thus collisions happened when they should clearly not have. Kunos did acknowledge this (thankyou again) and did address the issues somewhat in one of the updates, but not nearly enough from a league perspective.
    But hey, its just 1 question and a request..

    Cheers
     
  7. Serge M

    Serge M Alien

    Proper response to contact between cars is needed as don’t want cars being thrown from light panel rubbing or small nudge which can happen now. Visual damage is far less important I think though. If parts are falling off your car in real life you would be forced to pit and probably retire. Only exception is maybe broken side mirrors, would like to see that but again not something I’d call critical

    On the other hand the current high penalty for contact between cars may have forced people to race cleaner...
     
    AmirHM likes this.
  8. HemiR

    HemiR Gamer

    This highlights video the first 59 secs shows the sort of damage I would love to see , wishful thinking I know,, but would be cool to have some level of visual parts damage added to the race immersion. as you see not all cars retire from damage but certainly get handicapped..
    Not sure if I'm allowed to link to video...apologies If not please delete.

     
    Vytautas Leonavičius likes this.
  9. gandlers

    gandlers Hardcore Simmer

    Re: Visual Damage
    Vital for online racing...really.
    You are meant to avoid contact you know?

    For me your post rings the alarm bells.
    Someone is only interested in the visual damage and to them it is vital...
    Why would they be so obsessed with see in the car damage caused by contact they should be avoiding?
    Sounds like a wrecker who gets their kicks from causing crashes and looking at the carnage, that would be the only reason for it to be VITAL to them IMHO
     
    SwaggyShaggy, D_Rod and M-Bimmer like this.
  10. ShredatorFIN

    ShredatorFIN Alien

    Tbh it plays a factor in endurance racing. Avoiding contact is always the goal, but even pros IRL have contact. I wouldn't go as far as saying vital, but preferably improvement over AC1 in both terms of visual detail and physics-wise. Nobody is expecting Wreckfest (I hope) but something more than AC1. Visual damage exact similar to AC1 wouldn't be a deal breaker, but it would be disappointing
     
    Last edited: Jul 17, 2018
  11. HemiR

    HemiR Gamer

    Thank you glanders for your input, I believe you have misread my post as you are misquoting it.
    I've not said visual damage is VITAL at all.. Yes It needs to be improved over what is In AC currently for immersion. not wrecking.
    What I said is vital is the need for better collision models so we can race closer and not have these weird collisions when we are nowhere near the backs of cars as Serge M also alluded to.

    Here's a link to my original post regarding collisions..which Kunos acted upon- note the fixed status. Unfortunately the pictures of the collisions models are no longer there.
    https://www.assettocorsa.net/forum/index.php?threads/collider-model-issues.35185/
     
    Last edited: Jul 17, 2018
  12. Tberg

    Tberg Alien

    I agree that an improved collision model is needed for ACC, because they aim for a far more competitive racing title than AC initially was. Regardless if it is on- or offline racing.

    You could say that they also have an entirely new online model of how to rate drivers, incidents etc, and the aim should always be to avoid contact, but the way the cars and track walls absorb impact in AC is questionable, not very realistic and with crashes having highly unpredictable results regarding which way and at what speed cars are thrown around. Though, a big part of the issues online could be/is ping related.



    That said, it's not a huge problem, but if looking at the aim of realism in ACC that Kunos has laid out, including collision/crash physics optimizations would be in sync with the immersion level they strive for.

    We don't need parts flying off the car or softbody physics like Wreckfest.
     
    HemiR likes this.
  13. Alistair McKinley

    Alistair McKinley Hardcore Simmer

    I would also love to see a better/improved collision and damage model in ACC.
    I do not except a damage model like in Wreckfest or BeamNG, of course. Something like Dirt4 - from a visual aspect (and not taking collisions into considerations, yet) - would be cool, though.
    The car deforms after a crash and parts of the car can fly off. That would be more than enough for me in ACC.

    Regarding collisions: I feel that contact in AC is too rigid - like the cars do not absorb impact. It would be superb if cars could go a bit more into each other - if you know what I mean.

    I am very curious how Kunos will implement damage and collisions and I am looking forward to seeing some teasers.
     
  14. PLebre

    PLebre Hardcore Simmer

    I dont see problems with colision at AC. Physics seems ok. Maybe with simplifyed mat, because machine limits.

    People must understand that the colision model is also a simplifyed version of the actual car model because of the same reason.

    Só there always some inch diference here and there between the two models.
     
  15. Turk

    Turk Alien

    When you see collisions between carbon fiber race cars bits flying off is often the only real visual damage. Carbon fiber body panels seem to hold their shape pretty well even if they've been mostly detached. But seeing carbon fiber shards flying if you hit someone would look the part.
     
    Alistair McKinley likes this.
  16. DoubleJ93

    DoubleJ93 Rookie

    I hope that the damage system in online races can be set to be penalizing like in iRacing (your race is screwed when your car is too damaged/wrecked).
    I'm not talking about the visual damage but a real damage system to punish overaggressive drivers and other dive bombers/wreckers.
    iRacing is already working on an improved damage model (a video is planned very soon).

    This and a good safety rating system like in iRacing.
    The Sportsmanship Rating system in Gran Turismo Sport is interesting too.
    iRacing has pretty clean races and it seems the same on GT Sport too (from what I heard).
    Otherwise, online races in ACC will be mostly a pushfest/wreckfest with useless spectacular visual damage.
     
    Last edited: Jul 26, 2018
  17. ShredatorFIN

    ShredatorFIN Alien

    Of course physics effects of damage is far more important than any visual damage. But there should be still imo some improvement on both, while focusing on physics side
     
  18. Alistair McKinley

    Alistair McKinley Hardcore Simmer

    What does that mean?
    That it would be cool or that it would be unrealistic?
    (Sorry, I'm German. :) )
     
    trucidatio likes this.
  19. Serge M

    Serge M Alien

    Means would look good/cool
     
    trucidatio and Alistair McKinley like this.
  20. LeDude83

    LeDude83 Alien

    That's already in AC. You can pick up engine damage from downshifting too quickly or aero damage from crashes. Suspension damage is also possible and leaves you with an off-center steering wheel while going straight.

    All of this will screw your race.
     
  21. Turk

    Turk Alien

    That it looks right. "looks the part" generally refers to people dressing a particular way. So a lawyer in a suit looks like we expect a lawyer to look. If he's in a tshirt and jeans he doesn't look like a lawyer.
     
    DM2zzion and Alistair McKinley like this.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice