1. Do you need support for Assetto Corsa Competizione? Please use the proper forum below and ALWAYS zip and attach the WHOLE "Logs" folder in your c:\users\*youruser*\AppData\Local\AC2\Saved. The "AppData" folder is hidden by default, check "Hidden items" in your Windows view properties. If you report a crash, ALWAYS zip and attach the WHOLE "Crashes" folder in the same directory.
    Dismiss Notice

Feedback from real-life drivers - discussion

Discussion in 'ACC General Discussions' started by Kondor999, Jan 21, 2019.

  1. Kondor999

    Kondor999 Gamer

    So, I know we're in Early Access, but it bothered me to read this scathing Steam review by Josh Webster - An actual Gt3 driver who's driven the Lamborghini Huracán at the Sebring 12h race (Weathertech GTD class):

    https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561197991230945/recommended/805550/

    Here's the review:

    I'm surprised at the amount of good reviews this has at the moment. I'm in for the long term here and I'm sure it'll be a polished sim by the end.

    I was really looking forward to getting behind the wheel - however I was horrified at the handling of the cars and how unrealistic the cars felt.

    I drove the Huracan GT3 car (which I've raced in real life at Sebring 12h) and the car felt like it was on ice and constantly sliding with TC engaging in the weirdest way.

    I find this sim even harder than driving the cars in real life. I've applied setups from real-world tests I've done in an effort to try and cure some of the handling issues but to no avail.

    I feel ACC has a long way to go yet before the handling becomes 'public friendly' as even a real racing driver is having issues completing 1-2 laps without crashing due to characteristics that aren't there in real life.


    Ouch.

    So: Has the Huracán changed at all since that review (dated Dec 27, 2018) was posted? Normally I wouldn't care about a Steam review, but the guy is a real driver and has even driven the car in question.

    Any comments/rebuttals from the devs? Is this a known problem?
     

  2. Similar Threads
    Forum Title Date
    ACC Controls & Peripherals TS-PC wheel FFB feedback Jun 17, 2019
    ACC Physics 1.0.2 update Force feedback (ffb) Lamborghini Huracán GT3 feels weird? Jun 9, 2019
    ACC Controls & Peripherals Force Feedback Post-Processing Jun 8, 2019
    ACC General Discussions Some early feedback/questions May 30, 2019
    ACC Controls & Peripherals Thustmaster TMX no force feedback May 30, 2019
    ACC Physics Does ACC support ABS feedback through wheel? May 5, 2019
    ACC Virtual Reality No Force Feedback SteamVR Apr 9, 2019
    ACC Virtual Reality Steam VR induces no Force Feedback Mar 23, 2019
    ACC User Interface Feedback on: The User Interface [Asseto Corsa Competizione] Feb 23, 2019
    Screens & Videos tactile feedback / bass shaker via Shake It. tutorial and demo here Feb 7, 2019
    ACC Virtual Reality No Force Feedback in VR Samsung Odyssey+ (ACC Version 5.0) Jan 16, 2019
    ACC Troubleshooting Force Feedback vibrations not stopping Dec 19, 2018
    ACC Troubleshooting Force feedback missing Dec 14, 2018
    ACC Controls & Peripherals Force feedback disappears after restarting the game. Dec 3, 2018
    ACC General Discussions My Feedback so far 0.3.5 Dec 2, 2018

  3. LeDude83

    LeDude83 Alien

    In today's world I'd triple check the trustworthiness of this user/review first.

    On topic: There seem to be complaints about the Huracan being a proper widowmaker popping up every now and then. I personally can't reproduce that, at all. Just yesterday I drove it around Misano fast after having driven other cars before. I felt at home in the car, immediately and had zero issues through turns, over curbs or when correcting oversteer. 4 or 5 laps without a single properly scary situation in default safe setup.

    Just like everyone else, this guy should provide a video showing how he drives. Especially since he's a pro (possibly), he should know how important that is. Maybe he's suffering from the "track of ice" bug that's been reported quite frequently.
     
  4. iv4n

    iv4n Rookie

    I don't think anyone would fake being a lower profile racing driver, and the guy has some pretty big credentials looking on his website.
     
    Kondor999 likes this.
  5. LeDude83

    LeDude83 Alien

    SMS has payed RL drivers for providing positive feedback and also bought PRC. PRC then stopped writing negative stuff about pCars and even deleted old articles. Instead they praised pC2 and bashed anything else out there.

    Go connect the dots.

    I'm not accusing him for any such involvements but still I consider the possibility.

    One thing is for sure: something is very wrong here because he says he can't drive 1-2 laps without crashing. Either he's exaggerating lile mad or he can't drive or he doesn't speak the truth.

    His lap times and some replays are now needed for further analysis. So far it's not worth much.
     
  6. trutya

    trutya Simracer

    to be honst the Huracan's behaviour has been changed after every release as far i can remember :D
    now it again feels much more grippy, i took it to Misano, it was way more stable in the fast right corners in S3 than before.
     
  7. Guidofoc

    Guidofoc Alien

    I guess we could ask him to try it again now.
     
  8. D.Jankovic

    D.Jankovic Alien

    1.1 hrs on record he probablly refunded it...
    Steam seriouslly need to add ability to review game only if you play it more than 2hrs... so people who buy and just leave damn negative review and never tuch the game again cant do it.

    Edit: And only review he has is negative one for ACC he is probablly scared that ACC will kick *** of iRacing :D
     
  9. sps_for_race

    sps_for_race Simracer

    Has been discussed before over here as well:
    https://www.assettocorsa.net/forum/...eneric-discussion.49816/page-161#post-1018204





    I have enjoyed driving the Lamborghini since the first release, like many others.
     
  10. sps_for_race

    sps_for_race Simracer

    What would he say about the Jag ?
     
  11. Chris 576

    Chris 576 Hardcore Simmer

    Be interesting to get a 488 driver to comment on the super slippery tyre model and inability to drive for quite some time once you go off.
     
  12. sps_for_race

    sps_for_race Simracer


    Changelog v0. 5 :
    - Improved tyre grip when tyres are overheated, such as after a spin.
     
  13. LeDude83

    LeDude83 Alien

    Nice detective work mate. Case closed.
     
    Salvatore Amato and chksix like this.
  14. trutya

    trutya Simracer

    anyway the Huracan feels better than ever IMO... didn't test the BMW and Bentley since the update yet. Ferrari looks easier to control aswell a bit.
     
  15. Kondor999

    Kondor999 Gamer

    What does SMS and PRC have to do with Josh Webster? Are you implying this guy was paid off to leave a negative review or something?

    I seriously doubt a professional driver, with an active (successful) career, would agree to do that.

    There’s also the fact that he is also praising the game and saying he’s in for the long run. Why would he say that unless this was honest criticism designed to improve the game? The same logic applies to the theory of him being some imposter: Why would a troll mix praise (that the game would eventually get sorted out) with what sounds like legitimate criticism?

    As far as him playing for only 1.1h, please recall this is a pro driver with a career. No offense, but he’s not someone just pretending to be a race driver! Obviously, he’s not going to sit there and waste a lot of time wrestling with a car he knows doesn’t feel right (having driven the car IRL, unlike us). I also doubt he’s got a surplus of free time in which to record laps and post them to prove anything to us. Remember - the guy isn’t just some random gamer. He’s an actual driver who’s likely accustomed to being paid for feedback of the sort you’re suggesting is required to convince you of his veracity. I think he’s way more likely to just check back in occasionally (maybe not until release) to see if the car’s been fixed.

    I think I will actually reach out to the guy and see if he will try out the car again and give us his updated review. I’m really surprised that some folks here are just casually disregarding the opinion of a driver who has actually driven this car in competition! Let me ask you: Would it even take you 1.1 hours to figure out a car in GT Sport doesn’t feel right?
     
    Last edited: Jan 21, 2019
  16. LeDude83

    LeDude83 Alien

    The Huracan feels absolutely epic and its "slideability" through turns keeps getting better and better. It's not gonna be a drift car and it's not fast this way either but with the current tyre model and FFB you can powerslide it out of the turns with great confidence. Only in the very beginning of EA you couldn't do that without spinning every 2nd or 3rd time but that issue was clearly identified and resolved (tweaks to suspension and camber gain of tyre model).

    After that the car really only felt bad when the "track of ice" bug struck.
     
    manudouet likes this.
  17. sps_for_race

    sps_for_race Simracer

    It was never that bad as he described, grip has improved, but not that much you would say its totally different.
     
  18. LeDude83

    LeDude83 Alien

    I'm not even going to pick this fight with you as you're already twisting my words and try to defend someone who has failed in delivering a decent review which should at least include that he only drove the game for a very limited amount of time.

    Sorry but --> ignore list.
     
  19. Epistolarius

    Epistolarius Alien

    Why would the devs have to reply to his review, just because he is a race car driver? They just need to let the finished game speak for itself. He reviewed an unfinished product after playing it a mere 1.1 hours, and probably encountered one of the known bugs while the majority of players by and large don't seem to experience the same issue with the handling. If this one experience settled his opinion of the sim that's his problem, though he wrote he's "in for the long-term", so we'll see.
     
  20. Kondor999

    Kondor999 Gamer

    No offense, but you’ve never driven the car IRL. So it’s hard for me to value your opinion over a pro driver who has.

    And you just said the “slideability keeps getting better and better”. Does that not imply that, at some point, the car wasn’t “slideable”? You’re essentially admitting there was a problem. The same problem Josh Webster noticed.

    Rather than spending all your time desperately trying to somehow discredit the opinion of someone who’s driven the car in competition, why don’t we instead try to engage with him and get more info to help the devs? Maybe the car drives more like the real thing now, but I’d really like to hear that from someone who’s actually driven it.

    Honest feedback (not paid endorsements - we’ve seen plenty of those turn out to be bogus) from real drivers is, to me, the most valuable information.
     
    Last edited: Jan 21, 2019
  21. Kondor999

    Kondor999 Gamer

    So, you’re saying the guy’s opinion is just the same as any random gamer?

    A pro driver who has driven the car in competition.

    You seriously believe that my opinion (or yours) should carry the same weight as his?

    Again, instead of just ignoring his opinion and blindly rushing to defend everything in ACC, maybe we should step back and at least consider the possibility that something was wrong with the car.

    Maybe that has been fixed?

    That’s all I wanted to find out. I didn’t want to get drawn into an extended debate about whether Josh Webster’s opinion is worth having. I already know the answer to that.
     
    bgil66 likes this.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice